15 Best Pregnancy-Safe Eye Creams in 2023

Many women often wonder whether they should use an eye cream to hide their dark circles and puffiness or leave them as they are. The issue is more perplexing for expecting moms since they just can’t pick a random eye-brightening cream or any other makeup product while pregnant. Being pregnant means your choice is limited to eye creams that are only safe to use during pregnancy.

In this post, we have rounded up some top eye creams for pregnant women. We have followed expert recommendations before picking each of them. As a result, the eye creams we have picked are effective and harmless for you and your baby.

How to choose an eye cream that is safe during pregnancy?

When buying an eye cream during pregnancy, look for the following:

Make sure your eye cream is free from harmful ingredients, especially retinol and salicylic acid. On top of that, your eye cream should be non-comedogenic so that it doesn’t cause clogged pores and acne during pregnancy. 

Well, you already know your skin becomes super-sensitive during pregnancy. Buying a regular eye cream may trigger allergic reactions. Instead, choose a hypoallergenic eye cream that can offer a smooth and wrinkle-free face. A recent study found that many eye creams have some active ingredients which act precisely to treat the sensitive areas around your eyes.

Pregnancy-Safe Eye Creams

Our Top 3 Picks

CeraVe Eye Repair Cream

If you are struggling with eye bags and dark circles under your eyes, then you might want to try the Eye Repair Cream from Cerave. Aside from treating dark circles and fine lines, it transforms your puffy eyes into sparkling, smooth, and healthy-looking eyes.

Why this is our top pick:

The cream is enriched with three essential ceramides to form the skin barriers around the eye areas. With the help of the MVE controlled-release technology, the cream does a great job of moisture retention throughout the day. Your skin will stay hydrated and moisturized even in the super dry season.

The eye cream has an NEA Seal of Acceptance and a low toxicity score (4) on EWG. Besides, its ophthalmologist-tested formula is fragrance-free, hypoallergenic, and non-comedogenic to ensure 100% safety for you and your baby. 

Key specifications:

• Size: 0.5 oz
• Key ingredients: Hyaluronic Acid and  Almond Oil
• Salicylic Acid-Free: Yes
• Retinol-Free: Yes

Neutrogena Hydro Eye Cream

Neutrogena Hydro Eye Cream is one of the most popular eye creams out there. Purposely made for delicate skin, its water-gel formula is lightweight and goes on nicely without drying out fast. No wonder why it has a very low toxicity score (2) on EWG.

Why this is our top pick:

This pregnancy-safe eye cream works excellently on dark circles and puffiness under the eyes. Its non-comedogenic formula helps to beautify your skin and prevent the growth of acne, pore, fine lines, and wrinkles. Thanks to the moisturizing agent hyaluronic acid, it makes the dry, puffy skin under your eyes supple and smooth. You will likely notice a difference right after you apply it.

Comes from a dermatologist-recommended brand, and the product is free from oil, fragrance, and dyes. Using this cream regularly will make you feel refreshed and look younger.

Key specifications:

• Size: 0.5 oz
• Key ingredients: Hyaluronic Acid, Niacinamide and Ceramides
• Salicylic Acid-Free: Yes
• Retinol-Free: Yes

ELEMIS Anti-Wrinkle Eye Serum

ELEMIS Anti-Wrinkle Eye Serum is a premium beauty product in this list of pregnancy-safe eye creams. This eye serum treats the areas around your eyes in a more advanced manner to reduce fine lines and wrinkles.

Why this is our top pick:

The cream is formulated with protein-rich ingredients to make your eye area look healthy and beautiful. The main components of this cream are Amino acid, Blue flower linseed, and Padina Pavonica. All these components work together to eliminate fine lines and dark circles under your eyes. You are less likely to experience any greasy or oily feeling since it has a lightweight formula to treat your skin gently.

“Since I started using this, under my eyes is significantly better,” raves one user on Amazon. While most users agree that “Achieving smooth and glossy eye skin is super easy using this gel.”

Key specifications:

• Size: 0.5 oz
• Key ingredients: Amino acid, Blue flower linseed, and Padina Pavonica
• Salicylic Acid-Free: Yes
• Retinol-Free: Yes

Pregnancy-Safe Eye Creams

Rated Highly by Parents and Experts

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Ultra Eye Cream

Fragrance-free eye creams are a must-have for individuals with sensitive eyes. The La Roche-Posay Toleriane Ultra Eye Cream will be a great addition to any skincare routine for sensitive skin. 

This lightweight eye cream with a soothing gel-cream texture is infused with clinically proven ingredients like neurosensine, niacinamide, and thermal spring water. The combination offers a healthy dose of hydration for the skin. It also contains shea butter, which helps soften and soothe dry skin. Plus, the minimalist formula acts gently on the eye area without causing any discomfort. 

Dermatologist and Ophthalmologist tested; the eye cream is free from drying alcohol, preservatives, parabens, and fragrances. Hence the cream is suitable for all skin types, from extremely sensitive to highly dry skin. 

Happy customers claim that this eye cream absorbs quickly on the skin. Also, it helps retain an optimal skin hydration level throughout the day. For the best result, La Roche-Posay recommends applying it at night prior to bedtime.

Andalou Naturals Coconut Water Eye Lift Cream

The second on our list of recommended creams is the Andalou Naturals Coconut Water Eye Lift Cream. This popular beauty product is enriched with nature-derived ingredients to add moisture and smoothness to your extra sensitive skin around your eyes.

Its skin-friendly formula delivers instant hydration, thanks to the combination of coconut water and aloe vera that makes the formula super moisturizing for your delicate skin. Also, the formula uses an ultra-refined elixir, AquaCacteen, which helps protect the skin from environmental stress and aggressors. Moreover, the nourishing and soothing properties of AquaCacteen help to reduce fine lines and wrinkles around your eyes.

Additionally, Andalou claims that it has utilized Fruit Stem Cell Science to prepare the formula so that it can help develop a protective coating on the skin surface to secure the eye areas from harmful bacteria while serving essential nutrients. No doubt that it will be a great addition to your nighttime skincare routine during pregnancy.

Mario Badescu Hyaluronic Eye Cream

Here comes another premium eye cream from the Mario Badescu Skin Care brand. It is enriched with Hyaluronic acid, a pregnancy-safe skincare ingredient with anti-wrinkle properties to soothe and diminish wrinkles. Besides, the nourishing formula provides the right amount of moisture to treat areas around your eyes exceptionally well.

The eye cream doesn’t leave any sign of a greasy or oily feeling because of its lightweight formula. Plus, it absorbs quickly and gently on your delicate skin without causing any burning sensation or similar issues.

Furthermore, the formula also contains safflower seed oil, aloe vera, and euphrasia. These ingredients are a great source of natural moisturization. Whether it is dark circles, eye bags, or fine lines, you can expect good results with consistent use for some time.

Queen Bee Naturals Best Eye Balm Peeper Keeper

This eye cream comes from a trusted brand. With skin-friendly ingredients such as olive oil and jojoba oil, it helps to restore the natural look to your eye area. Even if you have sensitive skin, you will not experience any burning sensation because it is precisely formulated to work well for dry, sensitive skin.

The nutrient oils among the active components go a long way to ensure your skin remains moisturized for a long time. It doesn’t contain salicylic acid and retinol, which are known as skin-drying agents. Moreover, these are the two common skincare ingredients you should avoid during pregnancy.

Also, the formula contains shea oil and vitamin E to ensure long-lasting hydration. Made in the USA, this natural eye cream can be a great support for transforming your dry and puffy eyes into smooth and soft ones.

Colorescience Total Eye Therapy

Colorescience Total Eye 3-in-1 is a premium quality eye cream for pregnant women. It’s been a popular choice among women for brightening areas under the eyes. Whether you have wrinkles, puffiness, dark circles, or fine lines, its powerful clinical formula can treat all of them effectively.

With SPF 35 rating, it also works as a pregnancy-safe sunscreen to protect areas around the eyes. The product comes in a handy design. So you don’t need to apply it with your hand directly. Simply apply the cream around the eyes using the metal applicator and massage it gently.

Aside from the mentioned benefits, it works impressively well to reduce the signs of aging. Moreover, the cream comes in 4 different shades to match your skin tone. Sadly, this premium eye cream has a high price point. But considering all the aspects, you won’t regret throwing some extra bucks.

Cetaphil Hydrating Eye Gel Cream

A well-known brand like Cetaphil will hardly let you down. Like many eye creams, it also has hyaluronic acid to keep the dry skin under the eyes hydrated. It also includes Licorice Extract, which is known for its antioxidant properties. The combination of Licorice Extract and Hyaluronic Acid along with Vitamin Complex brightens and nourishes the skin.

The formula is lightweight to get absorbed quickly on the eye skin. Don’t worry about your sensitive eyes because it is dermatologist tested and proven safe for sensitive skin types.

Moreover, the cream is enriched with many nutrients to reduce signs of aging. With daily use, it will make the areas under your eyes look glowing and smooth.

Other Recommended Pregnancy-Safe Eye Creams

Supergoop! Bright-Eyed 100% Mineral Eye Cream

It is quite tough to find an effective and 100% safe eye cream for pregnancy. Give Supergoop Mineral Eye Cream a try, and you will be surprised with the results. The mineral-based formula of this eye cream helps restore the natural appearance of your skin.

Free from artificial colors, preservatives, and toxins, this might be the eye cream you are looking for during pregnancy. In addition, the eye cream is 100% mineral-based, which will calm your worried mind during pregnancy. It also eliminates the visual sign of fine lines and recovers sun-damaged skin.

Furthermore, the formula is very luxurious and lightweight, so it quickly gets absorbed into the skin. Happy customers claim that Supergoop transforms overly dry skin into a super moisturizing one.

RoC Multi Correxion 5-in-1 Anti-Aging Eye Cream

Wrinkles, puffy eyes, and dark circles are common skin issues among pregnant women. RoC Multi Correxion Eye Cream might be a good option to bring your puffy and tired eyes to life. In this Multi Correxion Eye Cream, RoC has combined its HexinolTM technology and powerful formula to deliver amazing results consistently.

Dermatologist-tested, it comes in a light, creamy formula that spreads easily. Since the formula is oil-free, it doesn’t leave any greasy or oily feeling around the eye areas.

The cream absorbs fast, even on the most delicate skin, without showing any sensitive effect. Most importantly, it improves the natural appearance of your eyes to make them look more attractive and charming. The eye cream is worthwhile to consider since it is easy to apply and delivers instant results.

Bliss Eye Do All Things

This eye cream comes in a cool-looking package that will surely get you excited. Its effectiveness in treating puffiness under the eye area makes it a great skincare product during pregnancy. From extra sensitive skin to normal, it is suitable for all.

The combination of botanical extracts, caffeine, and peptide ingredients works like a charm to make your skin brighter and smoother. All these components are highly beneficial in providing essential moisturization to your dry skin. Also, the creamy texture of the formula is excellent for under-eye makeup as well.

The steel roller ball applicator is another cool feature of this eye cream. The eye cream is free from most harsh chemicals, including parabens, phthalates, SLS, and more. However, users with sensitive skin find it a bit irritating. Other than this, the cream is worth giving a try.

Sunday Riley Auto Correct Eye Contour Cream

Did you know that caffeine helps eliminate free radicals and brightens the skin? The Sunday Riley Auto Correct Eye Contour Cream is packed with caffeine and light-reflecting particles to diminish wrinkles under your eyes. 

Along with caffeine, this fabulous eye cream also contains horse chestnut, ginseng, caffeine, and glycolic acid. These clinically proven skincare ingredients help improve fine lines, wrinkles, and overall undereye look. You will be glad to see quick results within a few weeks.

Moreover, Sunday Riley’s lightweight formula keeps your dry skin moisturized and nourished with essential skin nutrients. For the best results, apply it in the morning and before going to bed.

Weleda Awakening Eye Cream

If you are looking for a cheaper alternative to the Sunday Riley Eye Cream, then check out the Weleda Awakening Eye Cream. This eye cream is the favorite under-eye cream of many expecting moms since it is natural and cruelty-free. Also, the formula is fragrance-free, hence compatible with highly sensitive skin.

You can slow down signs of aging using it because the formula contains anti-aging properties. The light formula acts gently and smoothly on the delicate areas around the eyes. Within a few weeks, you will notice good improvements in your fine lines and wrinkles.

Furthermore, it doesn’t show any sign of a burning sensation or irritation in your eyes. You can use this eye cream worry-free since it is a dermatologist-recommended product.

Pacifica Glow Baby Eye Bright Cream Cream

Pacifica needs no introduction since it is well-known for making quality skincare products. Whether you are struggling with dark circles, eye puffiness, or under-eye bags during pregnancy, this Pacifica Glow Baby Eye Bright Cream is a safe and effective option for you.

Apart from these, it also gives your skin a youthful look by keeping your dry skin hydrated and refreshed. The brightening cream is made from the highest quality ingredients to ensure compatibility with super-sensitive skin.

Moreover, it doesn’t contain any toxins such as gluten and parabens, so pregnant women can use it without worry. Also, it makes your skin healthy by boosting blood circulation around the eyes. With this anti-aging formula, you will get fresh, beautiful, and smooth skin in no time.

Conclusion

Taking care of yourself should be your top priority during pregnancy. Aside from eating a balanced and healthy diet, you also need to keep your skin healthy. That’s why you need to pick an eye cream that is safe and effective during pregnancy. Our recommended pregnancy-safe eye cream will surely improve the skin areas under the eyes and bring back the real you.